Elliot Kaufman, writing on NRO, has a story of a ray of hope at a university. Do read the whole thing and check out the video that it links to. A cynic might conclude that the cloud of the mob means that hope is forlorn at our universities despite a few brave folks.
The story: The Evergreen State College in Olympia, Washington describes itself as, “A progressive, public liberal arts and sciences college.” It has a day of absence each year on April 12 when students and faculty of color meet off campus. It also has a day of presence but that is not part of this story. This year, allegedly because of the recent election, folks wanted reverse the situation and evict all the whites from the campus. Elliot reports what happened first:
One liberal biology professor, Bret Weinstein, took issue with this change. Weinstein wrote a powerful e-mail to his colleagues on March 15. Deeply respectful and generous in tone, he made a simple point: There is a huge difference between a group or coalition deciding to voluntarily absent themselves from a shared space in order to highlight their vital and underappreciated roles . . . and a group or coalition encouraging another group to go away. The first is a forceful call to consciousness which is, of course, crippling to the logic of oppression. The second is a show of force, and an act of oppression in and of itself. You may take this letter as a formal protest of this year’s structure, and you may assume I will be on campus on the Day of Absence.
You will not be surprised how these folks reacted to the professor. Elliot says:
Students occupied and barricaded the campus library, and accosted Weinstein outside his classroom. As you can see in this video, the mob surrounded him, yelled at him, swore at him, and openly admitted they did not want to allow him to respond. In the video, Weinstein nobly seeks to engage in “dialectic” with the student protesters, hoping to use “disagreement to discover the truth.” For a professor of biology, this is rather impressive stuff. But he misjudges the mob. “We don’t care what terms you want to speak on,” one student explains to supportive cheers. “This is not about you. We are not speaking on terms — on terms of white privilege. This is not a discussion. You have lost that one.”
Elliot concludes by asking what the students, faculty, and administration will do about this injustice. He reports that two students stood with the faculty member. There is no report of the faculty or administration supporting him. Eugene Volokh reports that an administrator confirmed that it would be safer for the professor to stay off campus.
Professor Weinstein and the two students are a small ray of sunshine. The inaction of the faculty and the administration in response to mob violence against free speech and especially reasoned speech are an enormous cloud of gloom. Universities exist for reasoned speech. We know exactly why universities are currently held in such low regard.