It has been building for years but the current hot item in TV shows and movies is for women to beat up men. Sometimes, like in Stargate SG1, Samantha (Sam) gets to beat up an alien man. It is a bit of silly fun. We have recently been watching Whiskey Cavalier (WC) and Blood and Treasure (B&T) where this behavior is happening all the time. The former is the better of the two although currently, the latter is the only one to be renewed. Or perhaps not. Why do we like WC better? The characters are interesting in WC. Lauren Cohan in WC looks intimidating but her pictures suggest otherwise. It may take awhile when looking a Lauren’s pictures but eventually you can bring your focus to her biceps. Her bulges are elsewhere. B&T has some interesting flashbacks but the main characters are not very interesting. In one particularly silly B&T sequence Gwen (Katia Winter check her arms too) beats up Bruno and then Bruno escapes from his cell by beating up two beefy policemen.
It is great fun having pretty women beat up big guys. Is it the cause of some of our current confusion? Men, on average, are stronger and faster than women. We see amazing women all the time but the strongest and fastest men are much stronger and faster than the strongest and fastest women. Military .com tells us about some amazing women. The US Army Ranger school has graduated twelve of them to date. They also tell us that 40 percent of the men pass but they don’t give a pass rate for women although it seems to be two or three out of nineteen. Elsewhere, there are assertions that there was an Army thumb on the scale for women:
But whereas men consistently were held to the strict standards outlined in the Ranger School’s Standing Operating Procedures handbook sources say, the women were allowed lighter duties and exceptions to policy.
We take no opinion on these assertions of the Army playing favorites other than to say hats off to the women and men that graduated and that any woman is highly unlikely to be the top scorer in Ranger school.
Sidebar: In running there might be some extremely long distances, like 100 miles where the top women can compete with the top men. In addition, boys and girls can compete equally at very young ages too. These exceptions are more proof of the general rule. End Sidebar
Here is some evidence from sports. Over the weekend the men (PGA) and and women (LPGA) both had a golf tournament on a par 71 golf course. The men’s course was 7,353 yards and the women’s course was 6,427 yards for a difference of over 900 yards or 50 yard a hole. There is a reason for separate tours. Of course, as Madeline Kearns reports at NRO, the transgender movement has led to unsurprising results. Connecticut allows men who identify as women to compete with women:
Since enacted in 2017, the Connecticut state [high school] conference policy has enabled two young men to win 15 women’s championships, titles that were held by 10 young women the year before. State athletic conferences in 18 other states have similar policies.
We don’t know if the fantasy of TV and movies has confused folks that women athletes can compete with men. It is not that a female can never beat a male. We have seen the women at the handball tournaments and many could hold us to three or less but they can’t compete with the men in the open class. It is just that the best woman has little chance against a pretty good man.
Let’s bring back Whiskey Cavalier. It is not a great show but it is interesting enough to renew. But we shouldn’t be confused that women can compete in athletics with men on the high school, college, or professional level. We shouldn’t let any group convince us that it is a good idea.